UNCHARTED: Legacy of Thieves Collection - PlayStation 5

The Verdict

Let me be blunt: if you’ve never played Uncharted 4 or The Lost Legacy, this collection is a no-brainer. If you have — well, it depends on how much you value 60 frames per second and DualSense rumble.

What’s Actually in the Box

You get two complete games on one disc (or digital download): Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End and Uncharted: The Lost Legacy. Both are remastered for PS5, not remade. That distinction matters. This isn’t a Resident Evil 4 style ground-up rebuild — it’s Naughty Dog’s engine pushed to its limits with the PS5’s hardware.

The collection includes both the base games and all previously released multiplayer DLC cosmetics for the single-player modes. There’s no multiplayer itself, though — that’s a separate free download if you want it.

Performance: The Real Story

Here’s where this collection earns its keep. On PS5, you get two modes:

Performance Mode (1440p upscaled to 4K, 60fps): This is the way to play. The jump from 30fps to 60fps transforms the gunplay. Fights that felt floaty on PS4 now snap with precision. The Madagascar chase sequence, already a showcase moment, feels like a different game entirely.

Fidelity Mode (Native 4K, 30fps): Slightly sharper, but honestly, the difference is minimal in motion. Unless you’re pixel-peeping on a massive OLED, Performance Mode is the clear winner.

Load times are the other revelation. From dashboard to gameplay in about 3 seconds. The PS4 version took 40-50 seconds for the same transition. Fast travel between chapters is effectively instant.

What Buyers Actually Say

The 4.8-star average across 240 ratings isn’t inflated. The critical consensus breaks down cleanly:

“The 60fps upgrade alone makes this worth it. I played through both games again and noticed things I’d missed entirely on PS4.”

“If you’ve never played these games, this is the definitive way. If you have, wait for a sale.”

That second quote is the honest truth. The DualSense integration is well-implemented — you feel the tension of Nathan’s grappling hook through the triggers, and haptics differentiate between walking on wood, stone, and metal. But it’s not a transformative feature.

Where It Falls Short

The $50 price tag is the elephant in the room. Sony has been criticized for charging full price for remasters, and this follows that pattern. If you already own the PS4 versions, you’re paying $50 for:

• A resolution and framerate boost
• Faster load times
• DualSense haptics
• 3D audio (requires compatible headphones)

The visual improvements are real but subtle. Character models look slightly better, textures are sharper, but don’t expect a Demon’s Souls style overhaul. The games still look like… Uncharted 4 and The Lost Legacy.

Who Should Buy This

Buy it if you’re:

• A newcomer to the series — you’re getting two of the best action-adventure games ever made, at their best
• A trophy hunter — both games have full trophy lists, and the difficulty is manageable
• Someone who skipped the PS4 generation — this is the definitive way to experience these games

Skip it if you’re:

• A PS4 owner who already beat both games — wait for a price drop to $30 or less
• Looking for multiplayer content — this isn’t the package for you
• Expecting a full remake — manage your expectations

FAQ

Q: Do I need to play the first three Uncharted games first? A: No. A Thief’s End works as a standalone story, though you’ll miss some character callbacks. The Lost Legacy is completely standalone with a new protagonist.

Q: Is the disc version worth getting over digital? A: Both games are on the disc — no download required. If you like owning physical copies or plan to resell, the disc version is solid.

Q: How long is each game? A: A Thief’s End runs 12-15 hours, The Lost Legacy about 8-10. Together, you’re getting roughly 20-25 hours of single-player content.

The Verdict

Buy it if: You want two of the best action-adventure games of the last decade running at their absolute best. The 60fps performance mode alone justifies the price for newcomers.

Skip it if: You’ve already played both games on PS4 and don’t care about framerate improvements. Wait for a sale.

Rating: 4.6/5 — This is a polished, definitive collection of two exceptional games. It loses points only for the premium pricing and lack of multiplayer. If you’re new to the franchise, this is the version to buy. If you’re a veteran, set a price alert and be patient.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.