Triclopyr 4 EC Compare to Garlon 4 and Remedy

The Verdict

Let me be blunt: if you’ve been paying name-brand prices for Garlon 4 or Remedy, you’re burning money. This Triclopyr 4 EC is the same active ingredient — 4 pounds per gallon of triclopyr butoxyethyl ester — at a fraction of the cost. The 229 buyers who left a 4.6-star average figured this out. Here’s what you need to know before you click buy.

What’s Actually in the Jug

You’re getting a 1-gallon jug of concentrated herbicide concentrate. The label reads “Triclopyr 4 EC” and lists the identical active ingredient concentration as Garlon 4 Ultra and Remedy Ultra. That’s not marketing speak — it’s the same chemical, same formulation type (emulsifiable concentrate), same EPA registration category. The difference is the sticker price.

The label covers the full spectrum: pasture brush, fence rows, right-of-ways, industrial sites, and non-crop areas. I counted the weed list — it’s comprehensive. Multiflora rose, poison ivy, oak, sumac, blackberry, kudzu, and over 200 other woody species are on there. This is serious brush control, not a cosmetic lawn product.

Real-World Performance

The chemistry does what it promises. Triclopyr is a systemic herbicide that translocates to the root system, which is why it kills the whole plant rather than just browning the leaves. One reviewer put it plainly: “Killed my multiflora rose patch that I’d fought with a mower and Roundup for three years. This stuff actually got the roots.”

Mixing is straightforward: 1 to 3 quarts per acre for foliar applications, or a 20-30% solution for cut-stump treatment. For basal bark work, you’ll mix it with diesel or crop oil at a 1:4 ratio. I recommend a dedicated sprayer — this stuff is oil-based and will linger in equipment.

What Buyers Keep Praising

The overwhelming theme in the reviews is cost-per-acre value. One verified purchase wrote: “Compared to what I was paying at Tractor Supply for Remedy, this is half the price and does the exact same job.” Another noted: “Used it on a 3-acre overgrown lot. One gallon did everything. My neighbor paid three times more for the same result.”

The cut-stump application gets specific shout-outs. Several buyers treated freshly cut tree stumps and reported complete kill — no regrowth sprouts months later. That’s the systemic action working properly.

Where It Falls Short

The odor is the first thing you’ll notice. It’s a strong, solvent-heavy smell that hangs around. One reviewer summed it up: “The smell will clear a room. Mix it outside, wear gloves, and don’t get it on your skin.” A respirator with organic vapor cartridges is worth the money here.

Second, this is not a lawn product. It’s non-selective and will kill grass, ornamentals, and anything else green it touches. If you have a small yard with scattered brush, spot-treat carefully or you’ll be reseeding bare patches.

Third, the concentrate is thick. If you don’t shake the jug vigorously before measuring, you’ll get inconsistent concentrations. A few reviewers missed this and wondered why results varied between batches.

Who Should Buy This

• Pasture and fence-line managers: This is your most cost-effective tool for reclaiming overgrown areas.
• Landowners with invasive brush: Multiflora rose, autumn olive, and honeysuckle don’t stand a chance.
• DIY stump treatment users: One gallon will treat hundreds of cut stumps at a fraction of professional costs.

Skip it if you need a selective lawn weed killer or you’re not comfortable reading a chemical label and measuring precisely.

FAQ

Is this exactly the same as Garlon 4? Same active ingredient (triclopyr BEE), same concentration (4 lb/gal), same use rates. The inert ingredients may differ slightly, but field results are indistinguishable. It’s a generic equivalent, like store-brand ibuprofen.

Will it hurt my lawn? Yes, if it touches it. This kills broadleaf plants including grass. Use a shielded sprayer or apply only to targeted brush. It’s not labeled for lawn use at all.

How long until I see results? Initial wilting in 7-14 days, complete kill in 3-6 weeks depending on the species and season. Woody plants treated in late summer or fall show slower top-kill but better root translocation.

The Verdict

Buy it if you need serious brush control and want to stop overpaying for the name brand. This is the same chemistry at a better price, backed by strong real-world buyer results.

Skip it if you need a selective lawn herbicide or you’re not equipped to handle a concentrated chemical safely.

Rating: 4.6/5 — Deducting points only for the strong odor and the need for careful handling. For the price-to-performance ratio, this is hard to beat for anyone managing brushy land.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.