Hykolity 35 Inch Fire Pit with 2 Cooking Grate & Charcoal Pa

The Verdict

Let’s be blunt: most fire pits under $150 are flimsy, rust-prone, and barely hold a flame. The Hykolity 35-inch model, with its 4.5-star rating across 225 reviews, claims to be different. After digging through the specs and what owners actually say, here’s the real story.

What You Actually Get

The box includes the fire pit bowl, legs, two cooking grates, a charcoal pan, a spark screen, and a fire poker. That’s a genuinely complete package — most competitors make you buy the cooking grates separately. The bowl is 35 inches in diameter and 12 inches deep, which is substantial enough for a real fire, not just a decorative flame. The steel is 0.8mm thick with a high-temperature powder coating, which is the key spec to check here — thinner steel warps and rusts out within a season.

Performance and Build Quality

In real-world use, this pit performs like a piece of equipment, not a toy. The dual cooking grates are the standout feature: you can use one for direct grilling and the other to keep food warm, or flip them both over for a full cooking surface. Owners consistently mention this in reviews. One buyer wrote, “We cooked burgers and hot dogs for eight people at once — the second grate kept the buns warm. Perfect setup.”

The charcoal pan sits at the bottom of the bowl, which serves two purposes: it lifts the fire for better airflow, and it makes cleanup dramatically easier since ash collects in a removable tray. That’s a thoughtful design choice that most budget fire pits skip entirely.

The spark screen is functional but not perfect. It’s held in place by gravity and a small lip, so in gusty conditions it can shift. Several reviewers noted this, with one saying, “The screen rattles in the wind. I put a brick on it when it’s breezy.”

As for the fire bowl itself, the 35-inch width gives you a genuinely large burn area. You can fit standard 16-inch logs without cutting them, and the depth keeps the flames contained. The powder coating held up well in reviews — no complaints about peeling or bubbling after several months of use, which is a common failure point on cheaper pits.

Where It Falls Short

Assembly is the biggest gripe. The legs bolt to the bowl with small nuts and bolts, and several reviewers mentioned stripped threads — you’ll want a socket wrench, not a basic screwdriver. Plan for 45 minutes and an extra set of hands to hold the bowl steady while you tighten everything.

The lack of a weather cover is another real omission. The powder coating is good, but it’s not impervious to standing water. If you live somewhere with regular rain, budget another $20–$30 for a cover or plan to move it under shelter.

Who Should Buy This

This is for the backyard entertainer who wants a fire pit that does double duty as a grill. If you host small gatherings and want to cook over an open flame while keeping food warm, the dual-grate setup justifies the price on its own. It’s also a solid choice for first-time fire pit owners who want a complete kit without researching and buying accessories separately.

Skip it if you’re a serious griller who needs precise temperature control — this is a wood or charcoal fire pit, not a propane grill. And if you’re mainly looking for a decorative piece, the utilitarian design won’t win any beauty contests.

FAQ

Is the charcoal pan necessary, or can I burn wood directly in the bowl? You can burn wood directly, but use the pan. It improves airflow for a hotter, cleaner burn and makes ash cleanup a five-minute job instead of an hour of scrubbing.

Can this be left outside year-round? Not without protection. The powder coating resists rust, but standing water will eventually find a weak point. Cover it or store it under a patio roof during wet months.

How hot does the cooking grate get? Can I use cast iron on it? The grates get hot enough to sear meat, and yes, cast iron skillets work fine on them. The steel is thick enough to handle the weight without bowing.

The Verdict

Buy it if: You want a multi-functional fire pit that cooks as well as it burns, and you value getting a complete kit without nickel-and-diming for accessories.

Skip it if: You need something you can assemble solo in under 20 minutes, or you want a decorative showpiece rather than a working outdoor appliance.

The Hykolity 35-inch fire pit earns its 4.5-star rating. It’s not perfect — the assembly and loose spark screen are legitimate annoyances — but for the price, the dual cooking grates, charcoal pan, and sturdy steel construction make it one of the better values in this category. It’s a buy.

Rating: 4.6/5

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.