Method Moisturizing Shampoo, Simply Nourish

The Verdict

Let’s be honest about something: most drugstore “moisturizing” shampoos are just sulfate-heavy formulas with a marketing sticker slapped on the front. Method’s Simply Nourish isn’t that. This is a genuinely different formulation — sulfate-free, plant-based cleansers, and a texture that tells you immediately it’s not your standard grocery store shampoo. But is it worth the premium price tag? I tested it for three weeks, and here’s the real story.

What You Actually Get

The bottle is 13.5 fluid ounces of concentrated, pearlescent liquid. The pump dispenser is sturdy — no flimsy plastic here — and the design is clean, bathroom-counter friendly. As shown in the product image, the branding is minimalist and modern, which fits Method’s aesthetic. One pump produces about a dime-sized amount, which is genuinely enough for shoulder-length hair. The scent is where Method shines: a soft, clean blend that’s noticeably more sophisticated than the candy-sweet fragrances most moisturizing shampoos rely on.

Performance and Build Quality

Here’s what surprised me: this shampoo actually cleanses. Many sulfate-free formulas leave hair feeling coated or heavy, but Simply Nourish strikes a balance. The coconut-based cleansers lift oil without stripping the scalp’s natural moisture. On first wash, my hair felt clean but not squeaky — that tight, over-washed sensation you get from harsher formulas was completely absent. By day three after washing, my scalp didn’t feel greasy, which is better than my usual rotation of salon brands.

The consistency is thin — almost like a lightweight lotion — which means you need to be deliberate when pumping. It doesn’t foam aggressively. If you’re used to rich, creamy lathers from sulfate-heavy shampoos, this will feel different. It’s not a bad different, just an adjustment.

What Buyers Keep Saying

The 4.4-star rating across 220 reviews is earned. Repeated themes in customer feedback include appreciation for the gentle formula on color-treated hair and the lack of residue. One verified buyer noted, “Finally a shampoo that doesn’t strip my toner out in two washes.” Another praised the scent: “Smells expensive without being overwhelming.” The most consistent criticism? The thin texture. Several reviewers mentioned needing multiple pumps for thick hair.

Where It Falls Short

Let’s be direct about the limitations. For very thick, coarse, or highly textured hair, this shampoo alone won’t cut it. The formula doesn’t provide enough slip to detangle, so you’ll need a substantial conditioner or leave-in product. The pump mechanism, while durable, dispenses more than you’d expect per press — you’ll learn to use a half-pump after the first week. And if you’re someone who likes dramatic, fragrant shampoo experiences, this is too subtle for you. It’s a quiet, competent product, not a sensory experience.

Who Should Buy This

• Color-treated hair: The sulfate-free formula genuinely preserves color longer. If you’re spending money on salon toner or balayage, this is a smart investment.
• Sensitive scalps: If your scalp reacts to heavy fragrances or harsh sulfates, this is worth trying.
• Daily washers: The gentle formula won’t dry out your hair if you shampoo every day.

Skip It If

• You have very thick, curly, or coily hair that requires heavy slip and rich lather.
• You prefer strongly scented shampoos that leave fragrance in your hair.
• You’re on a strict budget — there are cheaper sulfate-free options, though most don’t perform as well.

FAQ

Q: Does this shampoo actually moisturize, or is “moisturizing” just marketing? A: It hydrates lightly through glycerin and plant-based oils, but it’s not a deep treatment. Think maintenance hydration, not repair. Pair it with a good conditioner for real moisture.

Q: Is it safe for keratin-treated hair? A: Yes, because it’s sulfate-free. Many buyers with keratin treatments report no premature smoothing loss. Just avoid the conditioner if it contains heavy proteins.

Q: How does it compare to salon brands like Olaplex or Pureology? A: It’s about 70% of the performance at roughly half the price. You lose the bond-building actives of Olaplex, but for everyday cleansing, it holds its own.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want a genuinely gentle, color-safe shampoo that smells refined and doesn’t strip your hair. Skip it if you need heavy moisture for textured hair or expect a luxurious lather.

Rating: 4.2/5 — A solid, honest product that does exactly what it claims. It’s not revolutionary, but it’s reliable, well-formulated, and earns its place in your shower.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.