Pyrex 2-Piece Glass Pie Plate Set

The Verdict

Some products just work, and the Pyrex 2-Piece Glass Pie Plate Set is one of them. It’s two identical 9-inch glass pie plates — nothing flashy, nothing complicated. But after 240 Amazon ratings averaging 4.8 stars, the consensus is clear: this is the pie plate set most home bakers should own.

What You Actually Get

The set includes two 9-inch round glass pie plates, each with a 1.2-inch depth and roughly 28-ounce capacity. They’re made from tempered soda-lime glass — Pyrex’s current formula — which is different from the borosilicate glass of vintage pieces but still oven-safe up to 425°F. The plates feature a classic fluted rim that gives pies that homemade, bakery-style crimped edge without the fuss of shaping dough over a sharp edge.

As shown in the product image, the glass is completely transparent. That’s a feature you’ll appreciate mid-bake when you can peek underneath to check if your bottom crust is browning without pulling the pie out and losing oven heat.

Real-World Performance

Here’s where the Pyrex set earns its keep. Glass conducts heat more evenly than metal pie pans, and these plates deliver consistently golden crusts with no scorched edges. One Amazon reviewer put it simply: “The crusts come out perfectly every time — golden on the bottom, flaky on the edges. I’ve stopped using my metal pans entirely.”

The plates handle the full bake-to-table cycle: straight from a 400°F oven to a wire rack, then to the table for serving. Pyrex’s tempering process makes thermal shock less of a concern than with cheap glass bakeware, though I’d still let hot plates cool slightly before running cold water over them — that’s just common sense with any glass cookware.

Cleanup is straightforward. Baked-on filling releases easily after a soak, and these plates are dishwasher-safe, though hand-washing will keep the glass clearer over years of use.

What Buyers Consistently Praise

The two-pack value is the most common theme in reviews. Multiple buyers note that having two plates means you can bake a pie for an event and a practice pie at the same time — or double a recipe without buying a second set. One reviewer wrote: “I bought these specifically for Thanksgiving — one pumpkin, one pecan. They both came out perfect and looked beautiful on the table.”

The clear glass also gets frequent mentions for making it easy to see when the bottom crust is done — something metal pans hide completely.

Where It Falls Short

The 1.2-inch depth is the main limitation. Deep-dish recipes calling for 2+ inches of filling will overflow these plates. If you only bake standard pies, you’re fine. If you’re a deep-dish enthusiast, look for a dedicated deep-dish pan.

There are also no lids included. Leftovers need foil or plastic wrap, which is a minor annoyance if you expected storage capability — check the listing carefully since product images can be misleading about what’s in the box.

Who Should Buy This

• Weekend bakers who want reliable, even results without buying expensive ceramic or stoneware
• Beginners who need a forgiving pan that won’t stick or scorch
• Gift-givers looking for a practical housewarming item that actually gets used
• Anyone who bakes pies for holidays — having two plates is genuinely useful

Skip it if you exclusively bake deep-dish pies or need storage lids included.

FAQ

Can these go from freezer to oven? Yes, but with caution. Pyrex recommends letting frozen dishes warm slightly before placing in a preheated oven to avoid extreme temperature shock. Don’t place a straight-from-freezer plate into a 400°F oven.

Are they truly dishwasher safe? Yes, but hand-washing extends the clarity of the glass. Over time, dishwasher detergent can etch glass slightly, making it look cloudy.

What’s the actual capacity? About 28 ounces per plate — standard for a 9-inch pie. A typical double-crust pie recipe fills these perfectly.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want dependable, even-baking pie plates that last for years and cost less than a single fancy ceramic pan.

Skip it if you need deep-dish capacity or storage lids.

Rating: 4.6/5 — Two solid, reliable pie plates that do exactly what they should. The shallow depth and missing lids keep it from a perfect score, but for standard pie baking, this set is hard to beat at this price point.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.