The Verdict

New Star Foodservice 50875 Aluminum Wide Rim Pizza Tray Review: The Commercial Standard for Home Ovens

If you’ve ever pulled a pizza from a cheap dark pan and found the bottom pale while the edges char, you understand the frustration. The New Star Foodservice 50875 takes the opposite approach — this is the same heavy-gauge aluminum tray pizzerias use, and it solves the two biggest home pizza problems: uneven heat and soggy crusts.

What You Actually Get

This is a 16-inch round pan made from 0.8mm thick commercial-grade aluminum. The standout feature is the corrugated (fluted) bottom — those ridges aren’t decorative. They lift the dough slightly off the pan surface, allowing hot air to circulate underneath. That’s what creates a crisp, evenly-browned crust instead of a steamed, pale one.

The wide rolled rim serves double duty: it’s sturdy enough to grip with oven mitts, and it lets the pan double as a serving tray. You can take it straight from oven to table without transferring the pizza. The entire pan weighs about 1.5 pounds — substantial but not unwieldy.

Performance and Build Quality

I’ve tested this pan side-by-side with a standard non-stick round pan, and the difference is night and day. The aluminum conducts heat aggressively — preheat it in the oven for 15 minutes before sliding your pizza on, and you’ll get a blistered, pizzeria-style bottom in 6-8 minutes at 500°F. The corrugation also helps with frozen pizzas, which typically suffer from soggy centers; the airflow prevents that moisture from pooling.

The build quality is legitimately commercial. The aluminum won’t warp under high heat, unlike thinner pans that buckle after a few uses. One Amazon reviewer noted, “I’ve had this pan for three years and use it weekly — it still looks brand new.” Another mentioned, “The wide rim makes it easy to grab with oven mitts, and the pizza slides right off onto a cutting board.”

Where It Falls Short

Let’s be direct about the tradeoffs. The pan is hand-wash only. Aluminum reacts with dishwasher detergent, turning dark and pitted. If you’re someone who throws everything in the dishwasher, this will look rough within months.

Second, the 16-inch size is a problem for many home ovens. Standard ovens have about 18 inches of interior width, but the rack slides can reduce usable space. I had to angle the pan to fit mine — workable but annoying. Measure your oven before buying.

Finally, there’s no non-stick coating. High-hydration doughs (above 65% water) will stick without oil or cornmeal. Use a light brush of olive oil on the pan, or line it with parchment for sticky doughs.

Who Should Buy This

• Home bakers who make pizza weekly — this pan will outlast three cheap non-stick pans
• People who want pizzeria-style crusts — the corrugation genuinely improves crispness
• Anyone hosting pizza nights — the wide rim makes serving and cleanup easy

Skip it if you exclusively use frozen pizzas (the pan works, but you won’t notice the difference), or if your oven is smaller than standard width.

FAQ

Q: Can I use this on a grill or in a wood-fired oven? A: Yes, up to about 550°F. The aluminum handles high heat well, but avoid direct flame contact — the pan is meant for radiant heat, not open fire.

Q: Will this scratch my pizza stone or baking steel? A: The corrugated bottom has slightly sharp edges. Place it on a sheet pan if you’re stacking it in storage, and avoid dragging it across your stone.

Q: Does it make frozen pizza taste better? A: It helps — the airflow prevents the soggy center that plagues frozen pizzas on flat pans. Use the preheat method and watch the crust brown faster than the instructions suggest.

The Verdict

Buy it if you’re serious about homemade pizza and want a pan that lasts a decade. Skip it if you’re a casual baker who won’t hand-wash or measure your oven first.

At 4.6 stars across 229 ratings, this is one of the most reliable pizza pans on Amazon. It’s not flashy — it’s just a professional-grade tool that does its job exceptionally well. For the price, it’s a no-brainer upgrade over flimsy alternatives.

Rating: 4.6/5 — a genuine workhorse with one significant caveat: the dishwasher issue. Respect the hand-wash requirement, and this pan will serve you for years.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.