NED4655EW1 Heating Element fit for Amana 279838 W10724237 NE

The Verdict

The $30 fix that saves you a $200 service call

When your Amana oven stops heating but the broiler still works, it’s almost always the bake element. And here’s the thing — the part is cheap, the repair takes twenty minutes, and the NED4655EW1 replacement element nails the job for a fraction of what a technician would charge. That’s the value proposition, and it holds up.

What’s in the box

You get exactly one thing: the heating element itself. It’s a U-shaped tubular element measuring roughly 16 inches across with two spade terminals at the base. The brushed metal sheath feels solid — not flimsy like some no-name replacements. No screws, no wire nuts, no instructions. If you’ve never swapped an element before, YouTube has a dozen walkthroughs, but you’ll need your own Phillips screwdriver and possibly pliers.

Real-world performance

This element matches the OEM 279838 spec for Whirlpool-built ranges — Amana, KitchenAid, Roper, and some Maytags. The mounting bracket holes line up perfectly with the rear oven wall, and the terminals seat into the wiring harness without cutting or splicing. Once installed, preheat times return to normal — roughly 10-12 minutes to 350°F, consistent with the original element’s behavior.

Heat distribution is even across the bake cavity. Cookies bake uniformly, casseroles bubble evenly, and there’s none of the hot-spot charring you’d expect from a poorly manufactured element. The metal sheath glows orange-red at full temp, which is normal and expected.

A buyer named Mike put it plainly: “Exact fit, no issues at all. My Whirlpool oven was dead and this brought it back to life for 30 bucks. Took longer to pull the oven out than to swap the element.”

What buyers consistently praise

The 4.2-star rating across 210 reviews reflects strong satisfaction. The dominant themes:

• Exact fitment — “Fits perfectly, identical to the original part I pulled out.” Repeated across multiple reviews for Amana, Whirlpool, and KitchenAid models.
• Easy installation — Most buyers complete the swap in under 30 minutes with basic tools.
• Price — At roughly one-third the cost of a service call, the value is obvious.
• Reliability — Several long-term reviews note the element is still going strong after a year of regular use.

Where it falls short

Let’s be honest about the tradeoffs.

No hardware included. You’re reusing the original mounting screws. On older ovens with corrosion, those screws can strip. Have replacements on hand or risk a frustrating trip to the hardware store mid-repair.

Tight terminal fit. The spade connectors on the wiring harness sometimes need a firm push — or a careful squeeze with pliers — to seat fully. It’s not a dealbreaker, but it’s a known friction point.

Generic packaging. Some buyers received the element in a plain box with minimal labeling. It’s a functional part, not a retail experience. If you want the peace of mind of OEM branding, the Whirlpool 279838 runs about $20 more.

One reviewer noted: “Works great, but the terminals were a bear to get seated. Had to use needle-nose pliers. Once connected, no issues.”

Who should buy this

• DIY homeowners with a dead bake element and basic tool skills — this is your part.
• Landlords maintaining Whirlpool-built ranges across multiple properties — buy two, keep one in the van.
• Anyone quoted $200+ for a service call — spend $30 and 30 minutes instead.

Skip it if you expect OEM packaging, want included hardware, or prefer paying a professional for the repair.

FAQ

Q: Does this fit my Amana model? Check the model number against the compatibility list — it covers most Amana, Whirlpool, KitchenAid, and Roper ranges using the 279838 element. If your oven has a visible glow at the bottom but won’t heat, this is likely the fix.

Q: Do I need to pull the oven out to install it? Usually not. The element is accessible from inside the oven cavity — remove the two Phillips screws at the base, pull the element forward to expose the terminals, disconnect the wiring, and reverse the process.

Q: Will this work for the broiler element too? No. This is the bake element (bottom). The broiler element (top) is a different part number. Check which element failed before ordering.

The Verdict

Buy it if: You have a Whirlpool-built range with a dead bake element and basic DIY confidence. It’s a direct fit, works as intended, and saves you a service call.

Skip it if: You want OEM branding, can’t handle snug terminal connections, or have an oven with badly corroded mounting points.

Rating: 4.2/5 — The NED4655EW1 does its one job well. It’s not flashy, but it’s exactly what a replacement part should be: correct, affordable, and reliable. For the price of dinner out, you get your oven back. That’s a fair trade.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.