Mecity Toaster With Warming Rack

The Verdict

Let me be straight with you: most toasters under $40 are the same gray plastic box with a heating element and a timer. The Mecity Toaster With Warming Rack actually tries to do something different — and for the most part, it works.

What You Actually Get

Out of the box, you get the toaster itself (stainless steel finish, about 10.5 inches wide), a removable warming rack that sits on top, and a crumb tray. That’s it. No frills, no accessories you’ll never use. The warming rack is the headline feature here, and it’s not just decorative — it’s a metal frame that props up pastries and bread above the slots so you can warm them without toasting them.

The controls are straightforward: a browning dial with 7 settings, a bagel button, a defrost button, and a cancel button. There’s also a “frozen” setting that extends the toasting time automatically. The extra-wide slots (about 1.5 inches) are a genuine upgrade over the narrow slots on budget toasters.

Real-World Performance

I’ve tested this against the standard $20 toaster you’d grab at Target, and the difference is noticeable. The 7 browning settings actually matter. Setting 1 gives you barely-warm bread — perfect for people who just want the butter to melt. Setting 5 produces a dark, crispy slice that holds up to heavy toppings. My personal sweet spot is 3 for white bread and 4 for whole wheat.

The bagel mode toasts only the cut side, which is how it should work. The defrost function takes frozen bread from rock-hard to properly toasted in one pass without burning the outside — something cheaper toasters consistently fail at.

The warming rack is the star, though. I’ve used it for croissants, english muffins, and even a slice of leftover pizza. It warms without crisping, which is exactly what you want for delicate pastries. As shown in the product image, it sits securely on top and doesn’t wobble during use.

What Buyers Consistently Praise

The 4.1-star rating across 204 reviews is honest. The most common praise centers on the warming rack — one reviewer noted, “This is the first toaster that doesn’t turn my croissants into crackers.” Another said, “The extra-wide slots handle my thick-cut sourdough without me having to jam it in.” Multiple reviewers mention the browning dial being more accurate than expected at this price point.

Where It Falls Short

Let’s be honest about the downsides. The crumb tray is shallow — you’ll be wiping the counter around the toaster more than you’d like. It’s removable and easy to clean, but it fills up fast.

The bigger issue is heat management. The warming rack gets genuinely hot to the touch during and immediately after use. If you have kids who might grab at it, that’s a real concern. The exterior stays cool enough, but the top surface doesn’t have the cool-touch protection you’d find on pricier models.

Also, this is a 2-slice toaster. If you’re feeding a family of four, you’ll be doing rounds. There’s no 4-slice version of this model.

Who Should Buy This

• Toast enthusiasts who want control: The 7 settings and bagel/defrost modes give you precision that cheap toasters lack
• Pastry lovers: The warming rack is genuinely useful for croissants, danishes, and bagels
• Small households: Singles, couples, or anyone who doesn’t need 4-slice capacity

Skip it if you need a 4-slice toaster, have young kids who might touch the hot warming rack, or you just want the cheapest possible toaster — this costs more than a basic model for features you might not use.

FAQ

Does the warming rack work for frozen pastries? Yes, but use the defrost setting first, then place the pastry on the rack for the final minute. It warms through without burning the outside.

Can you toast bagels in the extra-wide slots? Yes, and it’s one of the best features. Thick bagel halves fit without forcing, and the bagel button toasts only the cut side.

Is the stainless steel finish a fingerprint magnet? It shows smudges more than a matte finish, but it wipes clean easily with a damp cloth. Not a dealbreaker, but something to expect.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want a toaster that does more than just brown bread — the warming rack is a legitimately useful feature, and the browning control is accurate across all 7 settings. Skip it if you need 4-slice capacity or you’re on a strict budget and don’t care about the extra features.

Rating: 4.2/5 — A solid mid-range toaster that earns its price with the warming rack and precise browning control. The heat-on-top issue and shallow crumb tray keep it from being perfect, but for most households, this is the right call.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.