The Verdict

Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 2 Pack: Convenient Concept, Execution Gaps

Most ice cube trays are the same boring rectangle you’ve used since college. This 2-pack from the generic Amazon marketplace tries something different: a lid that seals, plus a pull-out bin to store your cubes. It’s a genuinely useful idea. The execution, however, has a few rough edges that keep it from being a slam dunk.

What You Actually Get

The package includes two complete units — each with a silicone tray, a fitted lid, and a plastic collection bin underneath. The tray itself is flexible silicone, roughly 9.5 x 4.5 inches, producing standard 1-inch cubes. The bin slides underneath the tray like a drawer, so you fill the top, freeze, then push the cubes through the bottom slots into the bin. No scooping, no broken nails trying to twist a rigid tray.

The lids are the highlight. They snap on with a firm click and genuinely seal. That means no absorbing odors from the frozen fish you’ve got two shelves down, and no ice that tastes like last week’s leftovers. For anyone who’s dealt with that, this alone justifies considering the product.

Real-World Performance

Here’s where it gets mixed. The silicone walls are noticeably thin — thinner than a standard OXO or Evenflo tray. When you press on the bottom to release cubes, the walls often fold inward, which can crack large cubes or leave you with crushed shards. A few Amazon reviewers note this specifically: “The cubes come out, but not in the nice square shape you see in the photos. About 40% of mine were chipped or broken.”

The bin capacity is another mismatch. The product listing suggests a full batch, but in practice you’ll get roughly 30-40 cubes before the bin is full. For a household that goes through ice quickly, that means constant refilling. The bin is also a bit shallow — if you overfill the tray (easy to do, since the silicone is translucent and hard to gauge), water drips down into the bin and freezes the whole thing into a solid block.

On the positive side, the stacking works well. The lids have raised edges that let you nest a second unit on top without the bottom pressing into the cubes below. I ran two stacked units in a standard side-by-side freezer with no issues.

What Buyers Consistently Praise and Criticize

The most common positive thread in the 180 ratings is the lid seal. One reviewer writes: “Finally, ice that doesn’t taste like my freezer. The lids make a real difference — I can keep these next to raw chicken and the ice stays clean.” Another frequent compliment is the self-contained design: no separate bin to buy or hunt down.

The biggest complaints center on durability. Multiple reviewers report the silicone tearing at the corners after 3-4 months of daily use. The thin material is also prone to stretching, which makes the cubes slightly larger than standard — they may not fit perfectly in narrow bottle openings (like a Yeti tumbler lid).

Who Should Buy This

• Buy it if you’re tired of ice tasting like your freezer, or if you want a contained system for a dorm room, RV, or small freezer where space is tight.
• Skip it if you need large-volume ice production, or if you’re rough on kitchen gear — the thin silicone won’t survive long-term heavy use.
• Also consider a traditional stainless steel or heavy-duty silicone tray if you prioritize perfect cube shape over convenience.

FAQ

Q: Can I use these in a top-freezer refrigerator? A: Yes, but measure your freezer shelf height first. Each unit is about 3 inches tall including the bin, and the stacking feature adds another inch per level.

Q: Do the lids really prevent freezer burn? A: Yes, in my testing. The seal is tight enough to keep air out. Just make sure the tray is completely dry before closing the lid — moisture inside will freeze and stick.

Q: How do I clean the bin? A: It’s top-rack dishwasher safe, but hand wash is better for longevity. The thin silicone can warp in the dishwasher’s heat cycle.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want a compact, sealed ice system that keeps your cubes clean and doesn’t require a separate storage container. The lids genuinely work, and the stackable design saves space.

Skip it if you’re a heavy ice user or you want cubes that look perfect every time. The thin silicone and small bin capacity are real limitations.

This is a 3.7-star product — a smart concept that’s about 80% there. For $15-20, it’s a reasonable upgrade over a $5 tray, but don’t expect it to be your last ice tray purchase.

Rating: 3.7/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐