Sugar Free Butterscotch Hard Candy Arcor - 2LB Bag (About 15

The Verdict

Let’s be honest: most sugar-free hard candies taste like regret wrapped in wax paper. So when a 2-pound bag of sugar-free butterscotch pulls a 4.7-star average from 235 ratings, that’s not luck — that’s a product doing something right. Arcor, an Argentine confectionery giant, has been making this recipe for decades, and it shows.

What’s Actually in the Bag

You’re getting a 2LB (907g) bulk bag of individually wrapped hard candies — roughly 150 pieces based on typical piece weights. Each candy is about the size of a standard butterscotch drop, wrapped in clear cellophane with a twist seal. The wrapper is worth mentioning: it doesn’t stick to the candy in humid conditions, which is a common failure point with cheap bulk candies.

The ingredient list is straightforward: maltitol syrup, isomalt, butter, cream, natural and artificial flavors. No aspartame, no sucralose aftertaste. That alone puts it ahead of most sugar-free options on the market.

Flavor and Texture: The Real Test

Here’s where Arcor earns its rating. The butterscotch flavor is genuinely rich — buttery, slightly caramelized, with a depth that most sugar-free candies can’t touch. One reviewer put it plainly: “I’ve tried every sugar-free butterscotch on Amazon. This is the only one that actually tastes like butterscotch, not vanilla-flavored chalk.”

The texture is where opinions split. Traditional butterscotch has a hard, brittle snap. Arcor’s version is slightly softer — closer to a medium-hard candy. It dissolves slowly and evenly, which makes it ideal for coffee drinkers who want something to suck on while sipping. But if you’re expecting that brittle crack of a Werther’s Original, you’ll notice the difference.

The sweetness level is also dialed back compared to sugar-sweetened butterscotch. It’s noticeable but not unpleasant — actually a plus if you’re pairing it with coffee, since it won’t overwhelm your palate.

What Buyers Consistently Praise

The recurring themes in the 235 ratings are predictable but telling:

• Taste authenticity: Multiple reviewers who “hate sugar-free candy” make an exception for this one
• Gentle on stomachs: The maltitol/isomalt blend causes far fewer digestive issues than sorbitol-based candies. One reviewer noted, “I’m sensitive to sugar alcohols and these don’t bother me at all — even after several pieces.”
• Longevity: The 2LB bag lasts. At roughly 150 pieces, you’re looking at a month or more of daily use
• Coffee pairing: Several reviewers specifically mention keeping a dish of these next to their coffee maker — the butterscotch and coffee combination is a classic for a reason

Where It Falls Short

No product is perfect, and this one has honest flaws.

The serving size math is annoying. The label says “about 150 pieces” but doesn’t list a per-piece calorie count clearly. You’re doing mental math to figure out portions. It’s a minor gripe but a real one.

The soft texture isn’t for everyone. If you want that hard candy crack — the sound and feel of snapping a piece in your mouth — these won’t deliver. They’re closer to a medium-hard chew that gradually softens.

The price per pound varies significantly. The 2LB bag is the sweet spot, but if you can only find the smaller bags, the per-ounce cost jumps noticeably. Buy the bulk bag or wait for a price drop.

Who Should Buy This

• Coffee drinkers who want a guilt-free sweet to pair with black coffee or espresso
• Diabetics or low-carb dieters who miss traditional candy but need sugar-free options that don’t taste like punishment
• People who keep candy dishes at work — the individual wrappers and neutral flavor make these office-friendly
• Anyone skeptical of sugar-free candy who wants to try a genuinely good version before giving up on the category

FAQ

Q: Will these cause digestive issues like other sugar-free candies? A: The maltitol/isomalt blend is gentler than sorbitol, and most reviewers report no problems. But sugar alcohols affect everyone differently — start with 2-3 pieces and see how you react. Don’t eat half the bag in one sitting.

Q: Are these actually sugar-free or just reduced sugar? A: Genuinely sugar-free. No sugar, no corn syrup. The sweetness comes from maltitol and isomalt, which are sugar alcohols that don’t spike blood glucose the way sugar does.

Q: How long do they stay fresh in the bag? A: The individual wrappers protect them well. Stored in a cool, dry place, the bag should last several months. The twist wrappers keep air out effectively, and there’s no powder residue or sticking between pieces.

The Verdict

Buy it if: You want a sugar-free hard candy that actually tastes good, especially for pairing with coffee or tea. The 2LB bag is a solid value at roughly 150 pieces, and the flavor quality justifies the price premium over generic sugar-free options.

Skip it if: You need that hard, brittle snap of traditional butterscotch, or if you’re sensitive to maltitol and isomalt. Also skip if you want precise serving information — the bag’s labeling is annoyingly vague.

Rating: 4.6/5 — Deducting a quarter point for the soft texture and another for the labeling. The flavor alone earns the rest.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.