Steak, USDA Choice New York Strip Steaks (8 oz) by Feed The

The Verdict

Is the “Feed The” USDA Choice New York Strip worth adding to your freezer rotation? At 4.2 stars across 210 ratings, the short answer is yes for most home cooks — but let me break down exactly what you’re getting before you hit buy.

What’s actually in the box

You’re getting individually vacuum-sealed 8 oz New York strips, USDA Choice grade. The product image shows the steaks as they arrive — cryovaced, not in butcher paper, which is the right call for freezer storage. Each steak is cut from the short loin, so you get that classic strip shape with a solid fat cap along one edge. No seasoning, no marinade, no gimmicks. Just beef.

Performance and build quality

I’ll be direct: these are solid grocery-store-plus steaks, not steakhouse cuts. The Choice grade means you’ll see decent marbling throughout — not the heavy, buttery streaks of Prime, but enough that a properly cooked strip stays moist. The 8 oz portion is honest; several reviewers confirmed the weights run true to spec, which matters if you’re tracking protein intake or cooking for a crowd.

Thickness is where things get inconsistent. Some steaks arrive at a lean 1 inch, others closer to 1.5 inches. That’s not a dealbreaker, but it does mean you can’t blindly set a timer — use a meat thermometer or you’ll overshoot the thinner cuts. One reviewer put it plainly: “The steaks were good, not great. Cooked one on the grill and it was tender, but I’ve had better from my local grocery for the same price.”

What buyers consistently praise

The packaging deserves real credit. Multiple reviewers noted the vacuum seal held up through shipping with zero leaks, and steaks that sat in freezers for months came out without freezer burn. That’s the single biggest reason people reorder — this is a “stock the freezer” product, not a “dinner tonight” impulse buy.

Flavor-wise, the Choice grade delivers exactly what you’d expect: clean beef flavor, decent marbling, and enough fat to handle a hot cast iron or grill without drying out. For weeknight strip steaks at this price point, that’s a fair trade.

Where it falls short

Let’s be honest about the limitations. These are wet-aged, not dry-aged, so you won’t get that complex, nutty funk of a premium steakhouse cut. They’re also not thick enough for serious reverse-searing — if you want a 2-inch tomahawk experience, look elsewhere. A few reviewers flagged shipping delays that left steaks partially thawed on arrival; that’s a carrier issue more than a product one, but it’s worth knowing before you order during summer months.

Who should buy this

• Meal-preppers and freezer-stockers: The vacuum-sealed 8 oz portions are ideal for portion control and long-term storage.
• Weeknight grillers: These cook up in 8-10 minutes flat, making them perfect for busy evenings when you want real steak, not chicken again.
• Anyone who wants Prime flavor on a Choice budget: If you’re not ready to spend $20+ per steak, these deliver 85% of the experience at a fraction of the price.

Skip it if you need uniform thickness for serious sous vide work, or if you’re chasing that dry-aged, steakhouse-level flavor profile.

FAQ

Q: How should I cook these? Straightforward approach: pat dry, salt generously, let sit at room temp for 30 minutes, then hit a screaming-hot cast iron or grill — 3-4 minutes per side for medium-rare on the 1-inch cuts. Adjust down for thinner steaks. Rest at least 5 minutes before slicing.

Q: Can I refreeze these after thawing? Technically yes if they’ve been in the fridge the whole time, but flavor and texture will suffer. Better to thaw only what you’ll cook within 48 hours.

Q: Are these grass-fed or grain-fed? The product doesn’t specify, but USDA Choice grain-fed is the standard for this price point. You’ll get consistent marbling, which is what you want in a strip.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want dependable, well-packaged strip steaks for the freezer that won’t break the bank. Skip it if you’re hunting for steakhouse-grade dry-aged beef or need perfectly uniform cuts for precise cooking methods.

Rating: 4.2/5 — Reliable, honest steaks that deliver exactly what they promise, with minor thickness inconsistencies keeping them from a perfect score.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.