REESE'S Assorted Flavored Snack Size

The Verdict

The 4.7-Star Snack That Actually Delivers on Variety

Let’s be honest: most “assorted” candy packs are a bait-and-switch. You get one good flavor and three fillers nobody asked for. The REESE’S Assorted Flavored Snack Size box breaks that pattern — and that’s exactly why it’s sitting at 4.7 stars across 235 Amazon ratings.

What You Actually Get

This isn’t a single product — it’s a rotating lineup of REESE’S snack-size offerings. Based on current listings and buyer photos, you’re looking at a mixed bag typically containing:

• Classic milk chocolate peanut butter cups (the gold standard)
• White crème peanut butter cups (the sweet, vanilla-forward twist)
• Dark chocolate peanut butter cups (the slightly bitter, grown-up option)
• REESE’S Pieces or pretzel variations (texture play, depending on batch)

Each piece is individually wrapped, snack-size — think 60-70 calories per piece rather than the 210-calorie full-size cups. The outer box is unmarked with nutrition details, so flip over individual wrappers if you’re tracking macros.

Real-World Performance

Here’s where this pack earns its keep. The snack-size format is genuinely useful — not just a marketing gimmick. Buyers consistently mention portion control as the deciding factor. One verified purchaser wrote: “I can grab one or two without demolishing a whole bar. Perfect for my desk drawer.” Another noted: “The white crème ones are dangerously good. I’ve reordered three times.”

The freshness factor holds up too. Individually wrapped pieces stay crisp and creamy for months — one reviewer mentioned stashing them in a camping cooler and finding them perfectly intact weeks later. The chocolate doesn’t bloom or develop that weird powdery texture you get with bulk bags.

Where It Falls Short

Honest tradeoffs exist. The snack-size format means smaller portions — if you’re accustomed to full-size cups, these feel bite-sized. Multiple buyers report eating three or four at a sitting, which somewhat defeats the portion-control purpose.

The variety is also batch-dependent. Some boxes arrive heavy on classic cups and light on the specialty flavors. If you’re specifically after white crème or dark chocolate, this assortment may disappoint — you’re rolling the dice on the mix.

And yes, it’s candy. The sugar content is what you’d expect from REESE’S. This isn’t a health product, and pretending otherwise would be silly.

Who Should Buy This

• Office workers who want a treat without committing to a full-size bar
• Parents packing lunchboxes — the individual wrappers are mess-free and portioned
• Party hosts setting out candy dishes — the variety keeps guests grazing
• REESE’S completists who haven’t tried the white crème or dark chocolate versions yet

Skip it if you want consistent flavor ratios, need full nutrition info on the outer packaging, or prefer full-size bars.

FAQ

Q: What flavors are actually in the box? A: It varies by shipment, but current batches typically include classic milk chocolate, white crème, dark chocolate, and either REESE’S Pieces or pretzel variations. Check recent reviews for photos of what’s shipping now.

Q: How many pieces are in the box? A: It depends on the listing size you choose — the assortment typically ranges from 18 to 36 individually wrapped pieces depending on package weight. Confirm the count in the specific listing before ordering.

Q: Are these the same as the ones in grocery stores? A: Yes, same product — you’re paying for Amazon convenience and delivery. The snack-size pieces match what you’d find in supermarket variety bags.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want a versatile, portion-controlled REESE’S assortment with genuine flavor variety and solid freshness. The 4.7-star rating is earned — this is one of the better candy variety packs on Amazon.

Skip it if you’re particular about getting equal ratios of every flavor, or if you need full nutritional breakdowns printed on the shipping box rather than individual wrappers.

Rating: 4.6/5 — A reliable, well-reviewed assortment that does exactly what it promises. Just don’t blame me when the white crème ones disappear first.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.