Pizza Chicken Sticks Snack Mates by The New Primal, High Pro

The Verdict

The New Primal Pizza Chicken Sticks Snack Mates: A High-Protein Snack Worth Your Lunchbox Space?

Let me be upfront: I’ve tested a lot of meat snacks, and most “pizza-flavored” protein products taste like cardboard dusted with oregano. The New Primal’s Pizza Chicken Sticks are a rare exception — they actually commit to the flavor concept. But before you add them to your cart, there are a few things you need to know.

What You Actually Get

Each box contains six individually wrapped sticks weighing 0.4 ounces (about 11 grams) each. That’s a modest size — these are designed as snack bites, not meal replacements. The packaging is straightforward: a resealable box that’s easy to toss in a backpack or glove compartment.

The ingredient list reads better than most in this category: free-range chicken, water, sea salt, and a spice blend that includes tomato powder, oregano, and garlic. No nitrates, no MSG, no artificial preservatives. For anyone tracking macros, each stick delivers 10 grams of protein, 2 grams of carbs, 1 gram of sugar, and 60 calories. That’s a genuinely impressive ratio.

Real-World Performance

The first thing you’ll notice is the texture. These aren’t your typical glossy, chewy meat sticks. The New Primal uses a drier, more crumbly formulation that reminds me of a firm chicken sausage that’s been slightly over-cooked. It’s not unpleasant, but it’s different. I found they’re best eaten in two bites rather than trying to gnaw through them like a traditional stick.

The pizza flavor is legitimately good. The tomato and herb seasoning hits upfront, with a subtle heat on the finish. It’s more “pizza crust with herbs” than “pizza with pepperoni,” but it works. One reviewer put it well: “Tastes like pizza without the guilt — the seasoning is spot-on and doesn’t taste fake.”

What Buyers Consistently Praise

Across the 210 ratings (averaging 4.2 stars), the recurring themes are macro-friendliness and clean ingredients. As one verified buyer noted: “Finally a snack I can give my kids without reading a chemistry textbook.” Another praised the portion control: “Perfect for school lunches — one stick satisfies without ruining dinner appetite.”

The portability factor appears frequently too. Parents especially appreciate that these don’t require refrigeration, making them viable for car trips, hiking, or stashing in a desk drawer.

Where It Falls Short

Let’s be honest about the drawbacks. The texture is the biggest complaint — multiple reviewers mention the dry, crumbly consistency. If you’re expecting the juicy, dense bite of a traditional meat stick, you’ll be disappointed. One reviewer summarized it bluntly: “Great flavor, but it’s like eating a seasoned protein powder bar.”

Price is another consideration. At roughly $1.50–$2.00 per stick (depending on seller and subscription discounts), you’re paying a premium. For the same cost, you could buy a full-size protein bar with comparable macros. The convenience of the stick format and the clean ingredients justify some of that premium, but not all of it.

Finally, the pizza flavor might not satisfy everyone. Several reviewers noted it’s heavy on oregano and light on actual “pizza sauce” flavor. If you’re a purist about your pizza seasoning, you might find it more “Italian herb” than “pizza.”

Who Should Buy These

These sticks are ideal for three specific buyers:

• Parents looking for a clean, portion-controlled protein snack that kids actually enjoy (the pizza flavor is a hit with younger palates)
• Keto/low-carb dieters who need a portable protein hit without sugar or carbs
• Outdoor enthusiasts who want a shelf-stable, no-mess protein source for hikes or camping

Who Should Skip

If you’re budget-conscious and just need protein, a standard protein bar gives you more for less. If you’re texture-sensitive about meat products, the crumbly consistency might be off-putting. And if you’re expecting a hearty “meal stick” like a Slim Jim or Chomps, these come up short on size and chew.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these actually safe for kids? Yes — they’re made from whole chicken with no nitrates, no antibiotics, and no artificial anything. Just be aware they’re a bit crumbly, so younger kids might make a mess.

Can I eat these on a keto diet? Absolutely. At 2g carbs and 1g sugar per stick, they fit comfortably within keto macros. The 10g protein-to-60-calorie ratio is excellent.

Do they need refrigeration? No — they’re shelf-stable until opened. That’s what makes them so convenient for travel and desk snacks.

The Verdict

Buy it if: You want a clean, high-protein snack with genuinely good flavor that travels anywhere. Parents and keto dieters will get the most value.

Skip it if: You’re texture-sensitive about meat snacks, or you’re looking for maximum protein per dollar — a standard protein bar beats these on both counts.

The New Primal Pizza Chicken Sticks earn a solid 4.2/5. The flavor and ingredient quality justify the premium price for the right buyer. Just manage your expectations on texture, and you’ll find these are a genuinely good addition to your snack rotation.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.