Party Sweets Color Buttermints

The Verdict

Let’s cut to the chase: these aren’t your average drugstore mints. Party Sweets Color Buttermints have carved out a loyal following among wedding planners and event hosts, and after testing them against the standard peppermint pillow crowd, I get why. But they’re not perfect — and you need to know where before you buy.

What You Actually Get

The package delivers a generous bag of pastel-colored buttermints — think soft pink, mint green, lavender, and pale yellow. As shown in the product image, these are the classic rounded-square shape, about the size of a thumbnail. The count varies by bag size you order, but the consistency is what matters: each piece has that signature buttermint crumble — firm enough to hold shape, yet tender enough to dissolve on your tongue without aggressive sucking.

Real-World Performance

Here’s where these mints separate themselves from the cheap stuff. The flavor profile is a gentle vanilla-mint blend — the mint is present but doesn’t smack you in the face like some commercial mints. The buttery undertone comes through clearly, which is the hallmark of a proper buttermint versus a generic sugar mint. Texture-wise, they melt slowly and evenly, leaving no chalky residue that plagues lesser brands.

I tested these at room temperature and chilled. Chilled, they’re firmer and last longer — a solid choice for summer events. At room temp, they soften slightly but don’t turn sticky or clump together in the bag, which is a common failure point for budget mints.

What Buyers Consistently Praise

Scrolling through the 220 ratings, a few themes dominate. One reviewer noted, “These are the only mints I’ve found that actually taste like the buttermints my grandmother used to keep in her candy dish.” Another highlighted the color variety: “The pastels are gorgeous on the dessert table — guests kept asking where I got them.”

The flavor consistency gets repeated shout-outs. Multiple buyers mention ordering these repeatedly for weddings, baby showers, and holiday gatherings, noting the taste doesn’t vary between batches — a reliability issue with many bulk candy sellers.

Where It Falls Short

Honesty time. The most consistent complaint in the reviews is breakage. These mints are delicate by nature, and shipping can take a toll. Several buyers reported finding a noticeable percentage of broken or chipped pieces in their bags. If you’re planning to use these as individual favors where presentation is critical, budget the time to sort through and discard damaged pieces.

The sweetness level is also worth flagging. These lean decidedly sweet — the buttermint profile is rich, not subtle. If you’re serving these after a heavy meal or alongside other sugary treats, guests may find them cloying after one or two.

Who Should Buy These

• Wedding planners who need bulk quantities in specific color schemes — the pastel variety is a major plus
• Event hosts setting up candy buffets or dessert tables where visual appeal matters as much as taste
• Anyone recreating a vintage candy experience — these deliver the authentic buttermint texture

Skip them if you need uniform, unbroken pieces for perfect favor packaging, or if you prefer mints with a sharper, more intense mint bite.

FAQ

Q: How many mints come in a bag? A: It depends on the size you order, but the standard party bag runs roughly 100-150 pieces. Check the specific listing for exact counts — they’re listed by weight, not piece count.

Q: Do these melt in transit during summer? A: Generally no — they hold up reasonably well in shipping. But if you live in extreme heat, consider ordering when temperatures are moderate or opt for expedited shipping.

Q: What’s the shelf life? A: Properly stored in a cool, dry place, these easily last 6-8 months. They don’t harden or lose flavor quickly, which is a plus for buying in advance.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want authentic-tasting buttermints with a beautiful pastel presentation for events, and you’re willing to sort through for broken pieces.

Skip it if you need pristine, presentation-perfect mints straight from the bag, or you prefer less-sweet confections.

At 4.2/5, these are a solid choice for the right buyer. They taste genuinely good, look attractive on a table, and deliver consistent quality — just account for the breakage issue in your planning.

Rating: 4.2/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.