Orville Redenbacher's Popcorn Oil, Butter Flavor, 16 fl oz

The Verdict

Opening Hook

Let’s be honest: most “butter flavored” popcorn oils taste like a candle that gave up. Orville Redenbacher’s version doesn’t. It’s the rare product that actually delivers on the movie-theater promise — rich, salty, unmistakably buttery — without turning your kitchen into a smoke-filled hazmat zone. At 4.6 stars across 229 ratings, this 16 oz bottle has earned its reputation. But is it the right oil for your popcorn routine? Let’s break it down.

What You Actually Get

The 16 fl oz bottle is straightforward: a clear plastic container with a yellow label, filled with a golden, semi-viscous oil. It’s a soybean and coconut oil blend infused with natural and artificial butter flavor. The ingredient list is short — no preservatives, no weird stabilizers. As shown in the product image, it’s a no-frills package, which is fine. You’re paying for what’s inside, not fancy packaging.

Performance and Real-World Use

Here’s where this oil shines: the smoke point. Butter burns around 350°F, leaving you with bitter, scorched popcorn. This oil holds steady at roughly 450°F, which means you can crank the heat, get those kernels popping hard, and not worry about your kitchen filling with acrid smoke. I tested it in a Whirley Pop and a standard stockpot — both produced fluffy, evenly coated kernels with zero burnt batches.

The flavor concentration is the real story. You only need about 2-3 tablespoons for a full batch, and it coats every kernel with that distinct, salty, buttery profile. It’s not subtle — this is unapologetically artificial, the kind of flavor that makes you crave another bowl. One reviewer put it plainly: “Tastes exactly like the popcorn at the theater. I can’t go back to plain oil.” Another noted: “A little goes a long way. I’ve had the bottle for two months and I’m barely halfway through.”

What Buyers Consistently Praise

The recurring themes in the 229 ratings are clear: flavor authenticity, longevity, and consistency. Buyers repeatedly mention that it doesn’t separate or go rancid quickly, even after months of storage. The butter flavor holds up batch after batch — no fading or weird aftertaste. One reviewer summed it up: “I’ve tried every brand. This is the only one that makes popcorn taste like the movies instead of like cooking oil.”

Where It Falls Short

Let’s be straight about the downsides. First, this isn’t a health product. At 120 calories per tablespoon and made with soybean oil, it’s a treat, not a daily staple. If you’re looking for a light, heart-healthy popping oil, this isn’t it — look to avocado or grapeseed oil instead.

Second, the artificial butter flavor (diacetyl) is intense. Some reviewers with sensitive stomachs reported mild heartburn or a heavy feeling after eating. It’s not a dealbreaker for most, but it’s worth knowing if you’re prone to digestive issues.

Third, the bottle design is mildly annoying. There’s no pour spout, and the oil is viscous enough that it clings to the rim. You’ll want a measuring spoon handy, or you’ll end up with an oily mess on your counter. Not a fatal flaw, but a consistent complaint in the reviews.

Who Should Buy This

• Home movie-night enthusiasts: If you’re tired of bland microwave popcorn and want genuine theater flavor, this is your oil.
• Whirley Pop or stovetop popper owners: This oil is specifically designed for high-heat stovetop popping — it performs beautifully.
• Gift-givers: It’s a practical, appreciated add-on for anyone who loves popcorn and hasn’t discovered flavored oils yet.

Who Should Skip It

• Health-conscious snackers: The calorie and fat profile is heavy. You’d be better off with air-popped corn and a light spray.
• People who prefer natural flavors: This is unabashedly artificial. If you want real butter flavor, you’ll need to add butter separately after popping.
• Occasional poppers: If you make popcorn once a month, a smaller bottle would serve you better. This 16 oz size is for regulars.

FAQ

Q: Can I use this in an air popper? A: Technically yes, but it’s not ideal. Air poppers don’t get hot enough to properly infuse the oil into the kernels. You’ll get better results drizzling it over freshly popped corn — just use about half the amount you’d use for stovetop.

Q: How long does the bottle last? A: With 2-3 tablespoons per batch, you’ll get roughly 10-15 full batches. Most reviewers report it lasting 2-3 months with weekly use. It stores well at room temperature, away from direct sunlight.

Q: Is this gluten-free? A: Yes. The ingredient list contains no gluten-containing components, and Orville Redenbacher’s doesn’t process this oil in a facility with wheat. That said, it’s not certified gluten-free, so if you have celiac disease, you may want to contact the manufacturer directly.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want movie-theater popcorn at home without the smoke, the mess, or the guesswork. It’s the closest thing to a professional popping oil you’ll find on Amazon, and at 4.6 stars, the crowd agrees.

Skip it if you’re watching calories, prefer natural ingredients, or pop corn less than once a month — in those cases, a smaller bottle or a healthier oil is a better fit.

Rating: 4.6/5 — It’s not a health food, but as a flavor and performance product, it delivers exactly what it promises. For the price per batch, it’s hard to beat.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.