Mediterranean Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 68 Oz Plastic Jug - Co

The Verdict

Here’s the thing about olive oil: most of what’s on Amazon is either overpriced glass-bottle snobbery or flavorless bulk swill. This Mediterranean EVOO in a 68-ounce plastic jug sits in a rare sweet spot — it’s affordable enough for daily drizzling but actually tastes like olives, not vegetable oil.

What you’re getting

The 68-ounce jug is the headline here. That’s 2 liters — roughly 45 tablespoons — of cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil. As shown in the product image, it comes in a sturdy plastic jug with a screw cap and a clear label showing both harvest date and best-by date. That date transparency matters more than most shoppers realize; a lot of “premium” oils hide their harvest year because they’re selling you two-year-old stock.

Build quality and real-world performance

Smell it before you cook with it. This oil has that fresh, grassy, almost tomato-leaf aroma that tells you it’s genuinely cold-pressed within the last year. The taste hits with a peppery throat burn on the finish — that’s polyphenols, the compounds that make EVOO actually good for you. Shoppers notice it. One reviewer put it simply: “Tastes like real olive oil, not the bland stuff from the grocery store. The peppery finish is a nice touch.”

It handles heat well for an EVOO. Sautéing at medium temperatures won’t scorch it, though you shouldn’t push it past 375°F. For raw applications — salad dressings, dunking bread, finishing drizzles — this is where it shines.

What buyers consistently praise

The value proposition dominates the reviews. At this size, you’re paying roughly half per ounce what you’d pay for comparable quality in a 500ml bottle. Multiple reviewers mention using it as their “everyday oil” — one noted, “I go through a bottle every six weeks for cooking and dressings. This jug lasts me months and the quality stays consistent.”

The freshness dates also get consistent callouts. Reviewers appreciate knowing exactly when their oil was pressed, which is distressingly rare in this category.

Where it falls short

Be honest about the plastic jug. EVOO is sensitive to light and oxygen, and plastic breathes more than glass. If you’re the type who buys one jug and uses it over six months, the flavor will degrade noticeably by month three. Transfer it to dark glass bottles if you’re storing long-term — or just accept that this is a “use it regularly” oil, not a museum piece.

The flavor profile is also a commitment. This is a bold, peppery, slightly bitter oil. If you grew up on mild, buttery California oils, this might taste aggressive to you. It’s excellent for savory cooking and salads, but I wouldn’t use it for baking where you want neutral fat.

Who should buy this

• Daily cooks who burn through oil and want quality without boutique pricing
• Salad dressing makers who want a robust, flavorful base
• Mediterranean diet followers who care about polyphenol content and freshness dates
• Skip it if you want a mild oil, need glass packaging for long-term storage, or prefer single-origin (Tuscan, Greek, etc.) certifications

FAQ

Is this oil actually extra virgin? Yes. The peppery burn and grassy aroma are consistent with genuine cold-pressed EVOO. Fake or heavily refined oils taste flat and neutral. That said, no lab certification is visible, so you’re relying on the producer’s claims.

How long does it stay fresh after opening? Expect 8–12 weeks of peak flavor if stored in a cool, dark cabinet. After that, oxidation takes over. Use it regularly and you’ll finish the jug before quality drops meaningfully.

Can I fry with this? Light sautéing and pan-frying up to medium heat — yes. Deep frying — no. EVOO has a lower smoke point than refined oils, and you’d be wasting the flavor compounds anyway.

The verdict

Buy it if you cook with olive oil daily and want genuine cold-pressed taste without the glass-bottle markup. This is an honest, fresh, well-priced everyday EVOO that outperforms many oils at twice the price per ounce.

Skip it if you’re a low-volume user who’d take six months to finish a jug, or you prefer mild, buttery oils. The plastic packaging and bold flavor profile make this a “use it up” oil, not a “savor it slowly” one.

Rating: 4.6/5 — Substantial value, genuine quality, and honest labeling. The plastic jug and bold flavor are tradeoffs, not dealbreakers. For the price per ounce, this is one of the best everyday EVOOs you can order online.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.