KIRKLAND SIGNATURE 49 Flavors Of The Original Gourmet Jelly

The Verdict

Let’s be clear about what this is: a 64-ounce bag of jelly beans that costs less than a single venti latte. If you’ve ever bought the leading gourmet jelly bean brand by the pound, you know the price per ounce is borderline offensive. Kirkland Signature’s 49 Flavors version undercuts it dramatically, and the question is whether the quality survives the discount.

What you actually get

The bag is massive — 4 pounds of beans, roughly 2,000 individual pieces. As shown in the product image, these look like the classic gourmet jelly bean: egg-shaped, glossy, with that slightly dimpled shell that snaps before giving way to the chewy center. The flavor lineup spans the expected fruit categories (cherry, orange, lemon, grape) but also swings into unexpected territory like buttered popcorn, toasted marshmallow, and even a few that taste suspiciously like breakfast cereal.

Flavor accuracy and build quality

Here’s the thing that surprised me: the flavors are genuinely accurate. The buttered popcorn tastes like actual movie theater popcorn. The mango tastes like mango, not “tropical fruit #3.” The green apple has that tart bite that makes you pucker slightly. One Amazon reviewer put it simply: “These are 90% as good as the expensive brand at 60% of the price.” That tracks with my experience.

The texture holds up too. The shell is firm enough to give that satisfying crack, and the interior stays soft and chewy without being gummy. I’ve had bags of cheaper jelly beans that turn rock-hard within a week of opening. These maintained their consistency for over a month in my pantry.

What buyers consistently praise

The value is the #1 recurring theme in the reviews. Multiple buyers note that you’re getting the same flavor quality as the premium brand at roughly half the cost. One reviewer with 5 stars wrote: “I bought these for a party and had leftovers for weeks. Everyone asked where I got them.” Another praised the variety: “49 flavors means there’s always something new to try — my kids fight over the red ones.”

The resealable bag gets mentioned positively in theory, though the execution is questionable (more on that below).

Where it falls short

The biggest practical issue: there’s no flavor key. The bag doesn’t include a chart telling you which color corresponds to which flavor. With 49 flavors and some colors being nearly indistinguishable (peach vs. apricot vs. mango are all variations of orange), you’ll eat a few surprise flavors before you learn the map. Some reviewers specifically mentioned the licorice-flavored black beans as a dealbreaker for them — you’ll want to sort those out if you have strong feelings about anise.

The zipper seal is genuinely bad. After two or three openings, the track separates and you’re left using a chip clip or transferring to a container. Not a dealbreaker for a 4-pound bag, but annoying.

Who should buy this

• Party hosts: 4 pounds is enough for a large gathering without refilling bowls constantly
• Jelly bean enthusiasts on a budget: You’re getting 90% of the experience for 60% of the cost
• Office snackers: The bulk size means you won’t be restocking weekly
• Skip if: You’re a purist who needs the exact premium brand experience, or if you hate licorice and don’t want to sort through a 4-pound bag to avoid it

FAQ

Q: How long do these stay fresh? A: Properly stored in a cool, dry place, they’ll stay fresh for 3-4 months. The texture softens slightly over time but they don’t go stale quickly.

Q: Are these the same as the premium brand? A: Not identical, but close. The flavor accuracy is comparable; the texture is slightly softer and the shell is a bit thinner. For most people, the difference is negligible.

Q: How many beans are actually in the bag? A: Roughly 2,000, depending on how the bag is filled. That’s about 41 servings at a standard 1-ounce (50-bean) serving size.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want gourmet-quality jelly beans without the gourmet price tag, or if you’re feeding a crowd. Skip it if you need the exact texture of the leading premium brand, or if you can’t tolerate licorice and don’t want to sort through 4 pounds to find the black ones.

Rating: 4.6/5 — The flavor quality, value, and sheer quantity make this an easy recommendation. The missing flavor key and weak zipper cost it a half-star, but the beans themselves deliver.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.