Hi Chew Candy Fantasy Mix - Rainbow Sherbet, Blue Hawaii, an

The Verdict

Let’s be straight about what this is: Hi Chew’s Fantasy Mix is a candy product, not coffee gear. But it’s the kind of thing you want next to your espresso machine or pour-over station — a bright, chewy palate cleanser between cups. And honestly, it might be the best thing to happen to your coffee corner since you stopped using tap water.

What’s actually in the bag

Three flavors, all tropical-leaning: Rainbow Sherbet, Blue Hawaii, and Blue Raspberry. Each piece is individually wrapped in the classic Hi Chew foil — which matters more than you’d think. The wrappers keep the candy from turning into a sticky brick in your bag or on your counter. You get a mix of all three in one package, so there’s no picking around a variety pack to find the good flavors.

The texture is worth calling out specifically. These are softer and more pliable than standard Hi Chew. The regular line has a firmer, almost gummy-adjacent bite. This Fantasy Mix is closer to a fruit taffy — it yields immediately, chews clean, and doesn’t stick to your teeth the way cheaper fruit chews do.

How the flavors actually land

Blue Hawaii is the standout. It tastes like pineapple and citrus with a hint of that “blue drink” tropical vibe — think a non-alcoholic Blue Hawaiian at a beach bar. It’s the most distinctive flavor in the bag, and the one you’ll be digging for.

Blue Raspberry is exactly what you expect: sweet, slightly tart, classic. It’s not groundbreaking, but it’s consistent and reliably good. If you like blue raspberry anything, this delivers.

Rainbow Sherbet is the weak link. The flavor is more vanilla-forward than sherbet-tangy. You get a hint of creaminess and a faint citrus note, but it lacks the bright, icy punch that real rainbow sherbet has. It’s not bad — it’s just the one you’ll eat last.

What buyers consistently say

The 4.6 rating across 229 reviews holds up when you read the actual feedback. A recurring theme is texture superiority:

“Softer than the regular Hi Chew, which I actually prefer. The Blue Hawaii flavor is incredible — tastes like a vacation.”

Another reviewer put it more bluntly:

“Bought these for a road trip. Bag was gone before we hit the state line.”

The most common complaint isn’t about flavor — it’s about portion size. Several buyers note the bag feels smaller than they expected. That’s fair. At typical candy prices, you’re paying a slight premium for the softer texture and the tropical flavor lineup.

Where it falls short

The value proposition is the main issue. You’re paying a bit more per ounce than standard Hi Chew for what’s essentially a texture tweak and a flavor swap. If you’re not specifically craving tropical flavors, the regular Hi Chew variety packs give you more candy for your money.

The Rainbow Sherbet flavor is a genuine miss for anyone who loves actual sherbet. The tang is muted, and the vanilla note dominates. It’s not bad candy — it’s just not what the name promises.

Who should buy this

Buy it if:

• You keep candy near your coffee setup and want something that won’t overpower your brew
• You’re a Hi Chew loyalist curious about the softer texture
• You crave tropical flavors and want variety without buying three separate bags

Skip it if:

• You’re on a strict per-ounce budget — standard Hi Chew is the better deal
• You hate when a “sherbet” flavor doesn’t taste like sherbet
• You prefer firmer, more traditional chewy candy texture

FAQ

Q: Are these gluten-free? A: Yes, Hi Chew products are gluten-free. They’re also made without gelatin, so they’re suitable for most vegetarians.

Q: How many pieces are in the bag? A: It varies by size option, but the standard bag runs roughly 15-18 pieces. Check the specific listing for exact count, as Amazon sells multiple size configurations.

Q: Do these melt in hot weather? A: They soften significantly in heat. If you’re shipping them or carrying them in a car during summer, keep them cool — they won’t fully melt like chocolate, but they’ll get noticeably squishy.

The Verdict

Buy it if you want a softer, more tropical take on Hi Chew and don’t mind a slight premium for the flavor variety. Skip it if you’re strictly value-driven or expect Rainbow Sherbet to taste like actual sherbet.

Rating: 4.6/5 — The Blue Hawaii flavor alone is worth the purchase, and the softer texture is a genuine improvement. It’s a solid upgrade for your candy drawer or coffee station, just not a revolutionary one.

Where to Buy

👉 Check Price on Amazon →

We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.

Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.